How to Respond to Psychology Today Inquiries: A Step-by-Step Workflow for Therapy and Mental Health Practices (2027)

By Ashleigh Atuahene, Co-founder, Ataraxis Management

The best way to respond to Psychology Today inquiries is to reply quickly, collect the same five details from every person, check fit against your written criteria, verify benefits, and book the consultation in your EHR. Inquiries that don’t book get a short follow-up sequence over two weeks. A trained virtual assistant can run this entire process for you, across every directory and inbox, without making any clinical decisions.

Before co-founding Ataraxis Management, I worked in healthcare administration across pediatrics, internal medicine and behavioral health, and I provided ABA therapy under a licensed therapist. The pattern I saw most often was that practices paid for directory listings, then lost the leads because nobody had time to answer them. This guide will create a workflow that fixes that problem.


Where inquiries come from

Most therapy practices get new client inquiries from more places than they realize. Whoever handles intake should watch every one of these channels every business day.

Source What comes in What to do

Psychology Today

Email inquiries and calls to the profile phone line

Reply to every email and return every call or voicemail

Zocdoc

Booking requests and messages

Confirm or reschedule, and collect intake details

Headway, Alma, Grow Therapy, Rula, SonderMind

Client referrals and messages, where your practice receives them

Respond inside the platform and follow its booking rules

Google Business Profile

Calls and messages

Return calls and answer messages

Website contact forms

Form submissions

Reply by email or phone, per the inquirer’s preference

SimplePractice and TherapyNotes client portals

Portal requests and messages

Answer in the portal and book the consult


The six-step response workflow

  1. Acknowledge the inquiry. Send a short, warm reply that thanks the person, confirms you received the message, and says what happens next. Keep clinical details out of it.

     

  2. Collect the details. Ask every person the same five questions:
    • What state do you live in?
    • Will you use insurance, and which plan? Or will you pay out of pocket?
    • In your own words, what would you like help with?
    • What days and times work for you?
    • Do you prefer telehealth or in person?

       

  1. Check fit against the clinician’s written criteria. Each clinician should keep a one-page fit sheet listing ages served, specialties, modalities and the states where they’re licensed. The assistant compares the inquiry to that sheet. If anything is unclear, the clinician decides.

     

  2. Run a benefits check before the consult. Verify coverage, copay or coinsurance, deductible and any authorization requirements, so cost isn’t a surprise at the first session.

     

  3. Book the consultation in the EHR. Schedule the consult in SimplePractice, TherapyNotes or your system, and send intake paperwork through the client portal.

     

  4. Log the outcome. Record the source, date, response time and result for every inquiry. More on this below.


When the inquiry isn’t a fit

Not every inquiry will match your practice. When it doesn’t, the assistant sends a warm referral message using your practice’s referral-out list, so the person still leaves with the next step.

This doesn’t mean making clinical decisions, but sometimes the misalignment is obvious. For example, someone could be looking for family therapy but your practice only offers pediatric ABA services. You want to make sure you understand their needs and expectations to determine whether your practice aligns, and if not, refer them to another practice that can help.

The assistant should never make clinical judgments. Anything that suggests risk or crisis should be handled by clinicians, following your practice’s protocol. The person also gets crisis information right away: they can call or text 988, or chat at 988lifeline.org, to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Anyone in immediate danger should call 911.


How to follow up with inquiries that never booked

Many people who reach out never book, often because life got busy or they felt unsure. A short, respectful follow-up sequence recovers a meaningful share of them. Here is the schedule we recommend:

Day Message

Day 1

A friendly check-in with two or three open consult times.

Day 3

A short reminder, plus an answer to the most common question (cost or insurance).

Day 7

A final offer of consult times, with an easy way to say “not right now.”

Day 14

A closing message offering to keep them on the waitlist or share referrals.


Track the result of each touch. After a month, you’ll know which step books the most consults, and you can adjust the sequence.

Keep messages private

Inquiry replies often go to personal email, text and voicemail, so keep them lean.

  • Use the minimum necessary. HIPAA’s minimum necessary standard asks practices to limit the information they share to what a task requires. Leave diagnoses and clinical details out of emails, texts and subject lines.
  • Follow your policy on voicemail. HHS says providers may leave messages for patients, but should limit the details, for example a name, callback number and appointment confirmation. If a person asks to be contacted a certain way, honor the request when it’s reasonable.
  • Work in your systems. The assistant should use a practice-issued login for your EHR, email and phone, so your own audit logs capture every action.


What you get each week: an inquiry log

A weekly inquiry log shows exactly where your new clients come from. It lets you see which directory brings clients who actually book, so you can drop the listings that don’t pay for themselves.

Source Date received Response time Outcome

Psychology Today email

Mon, 9:12 a.m.

40 minutes

Consult booked

Google Business Profile call

Mon, 1:30 p.m.

2 hours

Not a fit, referred out

Website form

Tue, 7:45 p.m.

Next morning

Follow-up day 3


Sample entries for illustration.

The weekly log becomes a valuable tool for identifying strengths and weak points in your inquiry process. Over time, it helps you recognize patterns in where inquiries originate, how patients behave, and which sources are most likely to result in a booked appointment.

As an example, I once worked with a practice that received most of its inquiries through insurance directories and referrals from other clinicians. We noticed a distinct difference between the two. Referrals from other clinicians were generally more likely to convert into booked appointments. Some patients scheduled quickly, while others took a week or two to follow through, but they often came back and booked eventually.

Insurance directory inquiries were less predictable. Some patients would call with questions, go through the intake process, and then never schedule. We realized that many were contacting several providers listed in the same directory, comparing their options before deciding who to see. Others had already chosen a provider based on proximity, availability, or another preference and were simply calling to arrange an appointment.

These weren’t just observations or assumptions. We tracked each inquiry and new patient intake, including its source, follow-up activity, and eventual outcome. Having that information helped us understand what to expect from different referral sources, where additional follow-up might be worthwhile, and how to prioritize our time.


Who should handle intake in a small practice?

For a solo or group practice of two to five clinicians, a part-time virtual intake coordinator is usually the right first hire. Intake, follow-up and insurance verification typically fit in 20 hours a week, and the clinicians get their evenings back. 

Ataraxis Management places experienced healthcare virtual assistants who handle directory inquiries, intake and insurance verification for therapy and mental health practices. Assistants work in your EHR, including SimplePractice and TherapyNotes, using logins that your practice issues. Every practice gets a signed BAA, and every assistant signs a HIPAA confidentiality agreement. Part time starts at $1,100 a month for 20 hours a week, month to month, with free, unlimited replacements.

Learn more about hiring a virtual assistant for therapists or a virtual assistant for your mental health practice.


FAQ

Can a virtual assistant respond to Psychology Today inquiries for my practice?

Yes. A trained virtual assistant can reply to Psychology Today emails and calls, collect intake details, verify benefits and book consults, while routing any clinical or crisis question to you.

How do I follow up with new patient inquiries that never booked?

Send short follow-ups on day 1, day 3 and day 7, then a final message on day 14 offering the waitlist or referrals. Track which message books the most consults.

Can I outsource patient intake for my therapy practice?

Yes. A virtual intake coordinator can handle inquiries, intake paperwork, benefits checks and scheduling, as long as your practice signs a BAA with the provider and controls the logins.

What should a virtual intake coordinator never do?

Make clinical judgments. Fit questions that aren’t covered by your written criteria, and anything involving risk or crisis, go straight to the clinician.

I run a three-therapist practice. Who should I hire for intake and insurance verification?

A part-time virtual intake coordinator with insurance verification experience in your EHR. At Ataraxis Management, that starts at $1,100 a month for 20 hours a week.

Ashleigh Atuahene is co-founder of Ataraxis Management. Before building the company, she provided one-on-one ABA therapy under a licensed therapist and spent years in healthcare administration, handling patient intake, scheduling, prior authorization, insurance, and documentation across pediatric, internal medicine, and behavioral health practices.

Ashleigh Atuahene - Success Story Profile Pic